Same Door, Different Journey: Finding the Map and a Place to Belong

By Yuci Chen, Trainee Clinical Psychologist

As an East Asian PsychD trainee who already had an established professional identity, I am often asked: “Why do you want to retrain as a clinical psychologist?”

It is a perfectly reasonable question. Yet, for me, it also reveals how easily some of the barriers experienced by first-generation immigrants can remain invisible. Perhaps another question is worth asking: “Why did you have to travel so much further to reach the same door?”

The pathway into clinical psychology and the wider psychological professions may exist, but knowing how to navigate it is another matter. For those entering from different countries, cultures, educational systems and professional backgrounds, the journey can involve learning not only the formal requirements, but also how the system works: its language, expectations, networks and unwritten rules. The door may be the same, but the journey towards it is not.

Invisible Barriers: Was This System Designed With People Like Us in Mind?

For immigrants like us, the journey can involve far more than finding the right qualifications, experience or job. Along the way, a quieter and more persistent question can begin to surface: Is this pathway really meant for people like us? And even if I find my way in, do I truly belong here?

The barriers can take many forms: learning to navigate an unfamiliar professional system alongside the immigration system; translating previous experience from other countries into a language that the system recognises; building professional networks from scratch; negotiating expectations around confidence, self-promotion and communication that may sit uneasily with how we were culturally socialised; and gradually learning the unwritten rules of a profession that others may have encountered much earlier in their journey.

These reflections sit within a wider context of documented racial inequalities in the NHS workforce. In the 2024 Workforce Race Equality Standard, white applicants were significantly more likely than Black and Minority Ethnic applicants to be appointed from shortlisting in 80% of NHS trusts, and a lower proportion of Black and Minority Ethnic staff than white staff reported equal opportunities for career progression or promotion (NHS England, 2025).

Perhaps most difficult to articulate is the question that can quietly follow you through all of this: was this system designed with people like us in mind? This does not necessarily mean that the door is deliberately closed. But when you repeatedly have to translate, adapt, prove, decode and find your own way through, it can become difficult not to wonder whether you were ever imagined as someone who would walk through it.

Chinese Psychology and Psychotherapy Community (CPPC)

It was against this backdrop that I met Anna, the founder of the Chinese Psychology and Psychotherapy Community (CPPC), through social media in 2015. Anna completed her clinical psychology training in 2026 and is now a clinical psychologist. Within a community of hundreds of members, only a small number of us have secured funded clinical psychology training places. We clicked almost immediately. Although our journeys were not identical, we recognised something familiar in each other’s stories: the barriers we had encountered, the persistence we had needed, the emotional toll the journey had sometimes taken, and the thicker skin we had developed while trying to find the map. Over time, these experiences had brought maturity, perspective and resourcefulness – strengths forged through adversity, but not without leaving their marks.

The word Chinese in CPPC is not defined by nationality. The community brings together people with Chinese heritage and cultural connections from a wide range of backgrounds, including people with roots in Malaysia, Singapore, Hong Kong, Taiwan, Macau and China, as well as mixed-heritage and second-generation communities. Our migration histories, languages, cultures, educational experiences and relationships with UK psychology can therefore be very different.

I was later invited to speak at a CPPC career fair and subsequently became involved as a speaker in an NHS interview workshop, as well as providing one-to-one mentoring support. My role was not simply to explain how to enter the psychology professions. It was also about helping others find their place within what can sometimes feel like unfamiliar professional territory: understanding its language, decoding its unwritten rules, and finding a pathway that made sense for them.

As Anna and I knew from our own experiences, navigating a system from the outside can feel very different unless someone has helped you read the map. Career fairs, interview workshops and mentoring cannot remove every structural barrier. But they can make knowledge that is often acquired informally through professional networks more visible and accessible and perhaps mean that the next person does not have to travel quite so far alone on this journey.

The Immigration Rules: The Waiting Game and Surviving in the Meantime

Anna and I are first-generation immigrants, and many members of the community share similar experiences. One of the most significant barriers for us was the interaction between immigration status, residency circumstances and eligibility for particular training or employment routes. These include routes such as Children’s Wellbeing Practitioner (CWP), Education Mental Health Practitioner (EMHP), Psychological Wellbeing Practitioner (PWP), Clinical Associate in Psychology (CAP), cognitive behavioural therapy and family and systemic psychotherapy training, not to mention clinical psychologist training (NHS England, 2022). At different stages of our journeys, some funded pathways and employment opportunities were inaccessible to us or constrained by the eligibility and immigration requirements that applied to our circumstances.

For some people, greater financial resources can create alternative options, including the possibility of self-funding certain training routes or paying international tuition fees. Many of us, however, were simply not in that position. A pathway may technically exist, but access to it can still depend on whether someone can afford to take it. Waiting was therefore not always a choice; at times, it was the only financially viable option.

This created a peculiar kind of waiting game. We could see the pathways, understand where they might lead and work towards the profession, yet some of the routes available to others were simply not available to us at that point in our lives.

For those of us whose route to settlement depended on long residence, the wait could extend to ten years. The UK Long Residence route allows a person who meets the relevant requirements to apply for settlement after ten years of continuous lawful residence (UK Visas and Immigration, 2026). Ten years, however, does not mean standing still. In the meantime, we still had to work, support ourselves, maintain our immigration status, gain relevant experience and continue finding alternative ways forward. One of the contributions I later brought to CPPC was sharing what I had learned from this experience: how to navigate around routes that were not yet accessible, identify alternative opportunities, and continue building relevant experience while remaining financially and professionally afloat. In many ways, it was about helping others keep moving, even when the most direct route was not yet open to them.

Got a Ticket to Enter the Queue: But How Do We Knock on the Door?

Eventually, becoming eligible to apply felt almost like finally receiving a ticket to enter the queue. It did not guarantee a training place or a job; it simply meant that we could finally compete for opportunities that many others had been able to consider much earlier in their careers and in their lives. This was also part of what motivated me to contribute to the interview workshops. My hope was that, once someone had finally received their “ticket”, they would be better equipped to navigate what came next: to understand the expectations, communicate the value of their experience, and give themselves the best opportunity to move through the queue without losing yet more years trying to decipher the process alone. After waiting so long for the chance to knock on the door, I wanted to help make sure that simply knowing how to knock did not become another barrier.

Sometimes widening access is not only about how difficult it is to get through the door. It is also about how long someone has had to wait before they are even allowed to knock.

Working Against Our Cultural Instincts While Honouring What Roots Us

Cross-cultural psychology has long described differences in the extent to which cultural contexts emphasise independent and interdependent ways of understanding the self (Markus & Kitayama, 1991). Research has also identified cultural variation in self-enhancement and in how modesty is expressed, while emphasising that modest behaviour is shaped by both personal and situational factors rather than representing a fixed cultural trait (Bond et al., 2012; Heine & Hamamura, 2007).

Many of us may have been raised within more collectivist traditions, where we learn the beauty of humility and its quiet strength: to speak about our achievements modestly, express emotions and disagreement with subtlety, preserve harmony, respect the dignity of others, and remain attentive to how our words might make another person feel. These are not limitations; they can be deeply valued relational strengths.

Yet entering a professional culture in which some of these values may be expressed or recognised differently can create an uncomfortable tension and an emotional toll. The very qualities we have learned to value may suddenly become less visible, or be interpreted differently, within another cultural context. For some of us, adapting therefore involves more than learning a new interview technique or professional vocabulary. It raises questions: What happens when a strength in one cultural context becomes almost invisible in another, particularly when competing for a place in a profession where being seen matters? And how do we learn to speak a new professional language without losing the values that have shaped us?

What Has This Taught Us?

Some of the conversations I have had with community members were challenging in unexpected ways. Questions raised by others sometimes made visible barriers that I had stopped noticing in my own journey, or had simply accepted as the price of entering the profession. Mentoring, interview workshops and career fairs therefore became less about passing on what I knew and more about collectively making sense of a system we were all learning to navigate.

Of course, there is no single journey into the psychological professions. These experiences are intersectional: immigration status and cultural background interact with socioeconomic circumstances, language, education, disability, gender, generation and many other aspects of identity, creating very different possibilities even within the same community. Research on migrant progression in the UK similarly shows how structural barriers can interact with unequal access to financial, social, discursive and psychological resources, shaping people’s opportunities to progress (Netto et al., 2020). There is a difficult paradox here. When a structural barrier becomes a wall, individual barriers can almost become secondary. Before someone can consider how their confidence, language, finances, disability, cultural background or personal circumstances might affect their journey, they may first need the “map” and the “ticket” that allow them to knock on the door.

This is perhaps why community has mattered so much to me. I was once lifted up by others in a similar way when I was trying to secure my first NHS job while still navigating immigration restrictions. A Japanese art psychotherapist, who is now also a systemic family therapist, helped me find a way forward when the route was difficult to see. She later told me that, when she was starting out, a Korean colleague, now a team lead, had similarly helped her secure her first NHS role. Perhaps part of what I am doing now is simply continuing that chain, passing forward the support I once received.

But perhaps widening access should ultimately aspire to something beyond helping people become better navigators of difficult systems. Community can help us find the map, but responsibility for widening access cannot rest with communities alone. The system also needs to remain curious about why some people need so much more help to navigate the landscape in the first place, and whether that help reaches those who need it most.

References

Bond, M. H., Lun, V. M.-C., Chan, J., Chan, W. W.-Y., & Wong, D. (2012). Enacting modesty in Chinese culture: The joint contribution of personal characteristics and contextual features. Asian Journal of Social Psychology, 15(1), 14–25. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-839X.2011.01357.x

Netto, G. (2020). Intersectionality, identity work and migrant progression from low-paid work: A critical realist approach. Gender, Work & Organization. https://doi.org/10.1111/gwao.12437

Heine, S. J., & Hamamura, T. (2007). In search of East Asian self-enhancement. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 11(1), 4–27. https://doi.org/10.1177/1088868306294587

Markus, H. R., & Kitayama, S. (1991). Culture and the self: Implications for cognition, emotion, and motivation. Psychological Review, 98(2), 224–253. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.98.2.224

NHS England. (2022). NHS funding for psychological professions training programmes. https://www.hee.nhs.uk/our-work/mental-health/psychological-professions/nhs-funding-psychological-professions-training-programmes

NHS England. (2025). Workforce Race Equality Standard: 2024 data analysis report for NHS trusts. https://www.england.nhs.uk/publication/nhs-workforce-race-equality-standard-2024-data-analysis-report-for-nhs-trusts/

UK Visas and Immigration. (2026). Long residence: Caseworker guidance (Version 25.0). https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/long-residence/long-residence-accessible