
If the week began with grand speeches about the ability of multilateralism to change the world the days that followed have put that notion to the strongest of tests, with parties failing to agree on almost any of the substantive questions that must be resolved to build a meaningful plastics treaty. Sam Winton breaks down the current state of progress and outlines attempts by the Chair to break the deadlock and achieve an eleventh hour miracle.
Many stakeholders believe that a weak treaty could be worse than no treaty at all, sucking the political life from future actions to meaningfully address plastic pollution in the coming years. To say that the new Chair’s Text proposed on Wednesday afternoon was a disappointment would therefore be the understatement of the century:
Definitions – Missing
Chemicals – Unregulated
Production – Unabbated
Just Transition – Optional
A Financial Mechanism – Unfunded
A Standalone Article on Health – Killed
Decision-making at COPs – Deadlocked
This is not the treaty that 3,700 delegates have gathered in Geneva to negotiate. This is not a treaty which meets the mandate of UNEA Resolution 5/14. This is, quite simply, unacceptable.

Delegates gather for an explosive plenary with frenzied huddles across the room digesting the new Chair’s Text Photo: Sam Winton
When news broke late on Tuesday night that the Chair was planning to present a new text on Wednesday it was clear that he considered the useful life of the contact groups to be over. Therefore, when they each convened this morning, the contact group meetings were largely ceremonial in nature with co-chairs and delegates thanking each other for their work over the past days. However there was also much confusion, frustration and at times anger expressed. Prior to these meetings co-chairs had not been provided a clear way forward for the rest of the week. Members have spent the last 3 days meeting intensely, late into the night, in an attempt to make progress. However, this work was not complete and in many cases has not yet been reflected in any concrete outputs. This raised the legitimate question of how the Chair could reflect on this progress which has not yet been reported to him, how can he possibly use information that he does not have to inform his text, and if he is going to base his text on his own consultations rather than the contact group discussions, why on earth have delegates been spending 16 hours a day with no breaks for food, let alone a rest, in a desperate attempt to complete these discussions. Co-chairs were certainly at a loss and shared the frustrations of members, promising to reflect them to the Chair in a lunchtime meeting. I anticipated that this may be a major thorn in the plenary when it convened. It may therefore have been almost fortunate that the text he produced was so bad that the mess of the morning was quickly forgotten.
With the plenary scheduled to commence at 4pm, and strong anticipation for what was to come, observers gathered in the Assembly Hall early. By the time the text was released, shortly after 3pm, there was quite a gathering, ready to read through the text together, all looking for our key interests. My initial observations were positive. The text is only 12 pages, has almost no brackets, the preamble is reasonable and the objective addresses both human health and the environment. However, holes quickly appeared. Key definitions such as Plastic Products, Lifecycle and Plastic Waste are missing. Text on chemicals has been completely removed from Article 4 leaving them unregulated. Article 6 addressing production has been deleted, as has Article 19 on health. Despite some divergence, these last 3 topics have strong bridging text proposals, each supported by over 100 members.
More detailed reading revealed that the rights of Indigenous Peoples is only referenced once in the preamble and all references to their knowledge and practices have been deleted despite widely supported text proposals from Canada. A scan of the key operative articles revealed that only Article 7 on waste management guarantees the use of ‘shall’ indicating legally binding requirements. Other articles use language such as ‘should’ or ‘shall endeavour to’ marking these as voluntary. Parties would not even be required to create a national plan. Furthermore, while a financial mechanism will be set up, there is no requirement for it to be funded and decision making is threatened by paralysis as the rules of procedure at COPs must be adopted by consensus. Myself and many of my fellow observers sat digesting this text with extreme concern. This was a complete capitulation, dropping all ambitious measures. Surely the Chair did not have agreement within the committee for such a text.
After introducing the text in plenary. Ambassador Vayas set out a concise path forward. He wished to move immediately to regional consultations on his text, produce a new iteration overnight, approve the new text at plenary on Thursday afternoon for legal review, and forward it to the diplomatic conference at a plenary on Thursday evening. While he did not wish to take member interventions in plenary, the strength of feeling was far too strong and the Chair was therefore forced to accept responses to his proposal.
‘We regret to inform you that the proposed draft text is completely unacceptable and we cannot accept it as a basis for further consultation’. With this statement from Columbia, the floodgates were opened and during the following two hours, over 100 members furiously and vociferously rejected the chair’s text:
‘This text does not have any demonstrable value to ongoing international efforts to address plastic pollution’ – Kenya
‘This is simply repulsive. It is not ambition, it is surrender. We will not saddle our future generations with a text as weak as this’ – Panama
‘We need to convey extreme disappointment at lack of balance in the text’ – UK
‘Voluntary national actions have not been enough in the past decades and they are not enough now. If they were, we would not be here’ – Ghana
‘We deplore the lack of a comprehensive binding approach in the treaty’ – Peru
For the sake of balance, I must reflect that the Like Minded Group were also unhappy with the text, somewhat inexplicably. Despite a complete capitulation, the group wanted more, spelling out a detailed scope article and definitions with the sole purpose of removing the risk of any interactions with trade. For the group to be given so much and still reject it makes the fact that they will be impossible to compromise with, clearer than ever.
Where do we go from here? This was the focus of discussions for the final hour of plenary. Many countries rejected the text summarily, demanding a new iteration be produced before further discussions occur, others wanted to have the proposed regional consultations to work on the text further. There is also a suggestion for a Head of Delegations meeting to work with the Chair on an interaction. No one could agree on a way forward, quelle surprise. With the committee in deadlock, a beleaguered Ambassador Vayas pushed through a move to an evening of regional and bilateral consultations, with a likely Head of Delegation meeting occurring in the morning. We are then expected to convene for a fresh plenary session in mid-afternoon by which time a new text should have been circulated.
It is anyone’s guess what form that text will take. Will new brackets be added for addressing in plenary? Will the Chair finally accept that there is no mutually acceptable landing zone for all members and propose a stronger text which could gain the support of a majority, leaving behind the unwilling. This would require the abandoning of consensus and the implementation of a vote to get the text over the line. I would be shocked if this occurs but I retain hope for a miracle. One thing is certain. Ambassador Vayas will be grabbing what few hours of sleep he can tonight with the stern words of the committee ringing in his ears and an increasingly precarious grip on the successful delivery of a treaty text. Thursday is decision day. Time is up and the world is watching.
Sangat bersih web site, terimakasih untuk pos ini.
Hmm apakah ada orang lain yang menghadapi masalah dengan foto di blog ini yang tidak mau dimuat? Saya mencoba menentukan apakah ini masalah di sisi saya atau blognya. Saran apa pun akan sangat dihargai.
very good submit, i certainly love this web site, keep on it
I got good info from your blog
Anda dapat jelas melihat keterampilan Anda di dalam pekerjaan yang Anda tulis. Sektor berharap ada lebih banyak lagi penulis penuh semangat seperti Anda yang tidak takut mengatakan apa yang mereka yakini. Senantiasa kejar hati Anda.
Nyata bersih website, hargai untuk pos ini.
Please let me know if you’re looking for a writer for your weblog. You have some really good posts and I think I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d love to write some material for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine. Please blast me an e-mail if interested. Regards!
Saya setuju dengan semua ide yang Anda sajikan dalam posting Anda. Itu sangat meyakinkan dan pasti akan berhasil. Namun, postingnya terlalu singkat untuk pendatang baru. Bisakah Anda memperpanjangnya sedikit mulai waktu berikutnya? Terima kasih atas postingnya.
I’m not sure where you are getting your information, but great topic. I needs to spend some time learning much more or understanding more. Thanks for great information I was looking for this information for my mission.
Saya benar-benar beruntung menemukan situs internet ini di Bing, persis seperti yang saya telusuri : D juga sudah saya bookmark.
Wohh persis apa yang saya telusuri, terima kasih atas posting.
Informasi yang berguna. Saya baru saja menelusuri hal-hal seperti ini dan saya senang menemukannya di sini. Terima kasih telah berbagi!
Saya setuju dengan semua ide yang Anda telah sajikan dalam posting Anda. Mereka benar-benar meyakinkan dan pasti akan berhasil. Namun, postingnya terlalu singkat untuk pemula. Bisakah Anda memperpanjangnya sedikit lagi mulai waktu berikutnya? Terima kasih atas postingnya.
I love it when people come together and share opinions, great blog, keep it up.
Hello my family member! I wish to say that this article is awesome, great written and include approximately all significant infos. I’d like to look more posts like this.
Absolutely written subject material, thanks for selective information.
Hello. fantastic job. I did not expect this. This is a impressive story. Thanks!
There is evidently a bunch to identify about this. I believe you made certain good points in features also.
Hai semua, Anda telah melakukan kerja yang fantastis. Saya tentu akan menyimpan ini dan kembali untuk melihat konten lainnya. Terima kasih banyak!
Menikmati mempelajari ini, sangat bagus, terima kasih.
Great post, you have pointed out some wonderful details , I likewise think this s a very great website.
Saya setuju dengan semua ide yang Anda sajikan dalam posting Anda. Itu sangat meyakinkan dan pasti akan berhasil. Namun, postingnya terlalu singkat untuk pemula. Bisakah Anda memperpanjangnya sedikit lagi mulai waktu berikutnya? Terima kasih atas postingnya.
Saya bersyukur bahwa saya mendeteksi web blog ini, benar-benar info yang saya cari!
Saya secara tidak sengaja menemukan website Anda dan saya perlu mengatakan bahwa saya sangat kagum. Teruskan kerja yang bagus.
Itu memang milik Anda! . Kita setidaknya perlu membuat orang-orang yang mencuri gambar ini mulai nge-blog! Mereka mungkin hanya melakukan pencarian gambar dan mengambilnya. Tapi tampilannya bagus!
Saya mendapatkan info yang bagus dari blog Anda.
Saya tidak bisa menahan diri untuk berkomentar
Saya biasanya tidak menulis komentar, tetapi yang ini benar-benar pantas. Isi yang sangat baik dan berguna. Terima kasih telah meluangkan waktu untuk menulis ini.
Postingan yang sangat berguna. Saya baru menelusuri informasi seperti ini dan saya gembira menemukannya di sini. Terima kasih telah berbagi.
Saya tidak sungguh luar biasa dalam bahasa Inggris tetapi saya menganggap ini sangat ringan untuk dibaca .
Halo, saya sekadar ingin mengatakan bahwa saya sangat menyukai membaca postingan blog Anda. Ini adalah tepat jenis informasi yang saya cari. Saya akan merekomendasikan ini kepada orang lain. Terima kasih telah berbagi.
Saya terkesan dengan situs internet ini, benar-benar saya adalah penggemar.
Postingan yang luar biasa! Saya menghargai cara Anda menguraikan semuanya dengan sangat jelas. Teruskan pekerjaan yang hebat!
Postingan yang sangat bagus. Ini memberi saya gambaran yang lebih baik tentang topik ini. Teruskan pekerjaan yang hebat!
Saya terkesan dengan situs internet ini, sungguh saya adalah penggemar.
Saya melihat banyak website tetapi saya percaya yang satu ini punya sesuatu yang ekstra di dalamnya
Postingan yang hebat. Saya benar-benar menikmati gaya Anda menyampaikan ide-ide ini. Teruskan kerja yang luar biasa!
Halo, saya sekadar ingin mengatakan bahwa saya benar-benar menikmati membaca postingan blog Anda. Ini merupakan tepat tipe informasi yang saya cari. Saya akan merekomendasikan ini kepada rekan-rekan. Terima kasih telah berbagi.
Wow! Ini bisa jadi salah satu blog paling membantu yang pernah kami temui tentang topik ini. Sebenarnya Hebat. Saya juga seorang spesialis dalam topik ini jadi saya dapat memahami usaha Anda.
Saya selalu peduli dengan topik ini dan masih demikian, sangat dihargai telah mengunggah.
Wohh baru saja apa yang saya cari, salam atas posting.
Terima kasih atas tulisan yang baik. Sebenarnya ini dulunya adalah sebuah materi hiburan. Terlihat kompleks menjadi lebih menyenangkan dari Anda! Namun, bagaimana kita bisa tetap berkomunikasi?
Itu memang milik Anda! . Kita setidaknya perlu membuat orang-orang yang mencuri gambar ini mulai nge-blog! Mereka mungkin hanya melakukan pencarian gambar dan mengambilnya. Tapi tampilannya bagus!
hi!,I like your writing so much! share we communicate more about your post on AOL? I need an expert on this area to solve my problem. Maybe that’s you! Looking forward to see you.
Postingan yang bagus. Ini benar-benar disusun dengan baik dan mudah dimengerti. Terima kasih telah berbagi pengetahuan ini.
Ketika saya awalnya berkomentar saya mencentang kotak -Beri tahu saya ketika komentar baru ditambahkan- dan sekarang setiap kali sebuah komentar ditambahkan saya menerima 4 email dengan pesan yang sama. Apakah ada sarana Anda dapat menghapus saya dari layanan itu? Terima kasih!
Hai semua, kamu sudah melakukan pekerjaan yang luar biasa. Saya pasti akan menyimpan ini dan kembali untuk melihat lebih banyak. Terima kasih banyak!
Sangat menarik detail yang Anda catat, sangat menghargai telah memposting.
Situs ini benar-benar merupakan panduan lengkap untuk semua informasi yang Anda inginkan tentang hal ini dan tidak tahu kepada siapa harus bertanya. Lihat sekilas di sini, dan Anda pasti akan menyadarinya.
Hi, saya rasa situs Anda mungkin memiliki masalah kompatibilitas browser. Saat saya melihatnya di Safari terlihat baik-baik saja, tetapi di Internet Explorer tampilannya saling tumpang tindih. Saya hanya ingin memberi tahu Anda! Selain itu, blog yang fantastis!